I've been seeing this on the news and
Facebook a lot lately. And rather than respond to every post I see in
regards to it, I feel it is just better to write a blanket statement
here. If this starts debate, fine. But I'm airing my opinion here and
now on the matter because I feel like people aren't looking at the
bigger picture. This is probably the first political post I've done
in awhile, and it's on the idea of raising the minimum wage.
First,
let me concede that, from a personal financial standpoint, yes, I
understand the desire to raise the minimum wage. Things are getting
more expensive all the time (movies alone used to be $5 for matinee
and are now upwards of $10 and this changed only in the past 4
YEARS). I understand that there are single-parent families out there
who are barely getting by supporting their respective families on the
minimum wage and they're not getting raises any time soon, despite
the fact they are working as hard as possible to make it happen.
It's
tough for a lot of people and we can all agree it isn't going to get
any easier. But can I ask something? Am I really the only one who
sees the flaw in demanding higher minimum wages across the board?
Because I think people are forgetting the most important thing to
factor in. If we raise minimum wage, where does that extra money come
from? If a grocery store raises the minimum wage it pays its
employees, where on Earth is the money coming from to pay those
people more?
The
fault I see in the logic of raising minimum wage is that things
become more expensive to balance that out. Your food gets more
expensive at the grocery store so the bag boy can make his $11/hour.
The movies and concessions get more expensive at the theater so the
janitor at the cinema can make her $11/hour. You get my point. My
point being that by making it possible for entity X to get more
resources, they have to exhaust more resources from entity Y. And
since entity Y will run out of resources quickly to make good with
entity X, they have to push that cost somewhere. So entity Y forces
the cost on entity Z (consumers) to recoup those loses. As such, no
one wins because all that extra money earned will just go to paying
more expensive things. Made more expensive solely BECAUSE we (you)
pushed for higher minimum wages. And then, in probably another 8
years, we'll demand wages be raised again because people are tired of
not being able to afford things only to repeat this pathetically
stupid cycle again.
The
reason I bring this up is because I recently saw a picture in regards
to this. The CEO of Dairy Queen had made a statement, saying he would
love to raise the minimum wage so that everyone could earn a “fair
wage” and continued to say that the current minimum wage leave
plenty in a state of poverty. And while there is SOME truth to that,
the fact it is said by the CEO of a big nation-wide company makes the
whole statement lose any real meaning. If you honestly felt like the
current minimum wage is that big a problem, then set the fucking
example and pay ALL of your employees more, the amount you think
they're worth. Don't rely on the government to force YOUR COMPANY to
do it for you. This is hypocrisy at its finest.
This
harkens back to the big “Smoking Section” ban that started way
back in 2006 (I think, at least in my state). For those who don't
remember, it was a big government push to make a law where various
establishments (restaurants were the big target here, but any public
indoor place) would not be allowed to have a Smoking Section. Now, I
don't smoke and I don't like being around smokers. But there are
people who smoke that still should be allowed to have their own
section to be served. Restaurants should have a choice in the matter
as to how they want their establishment to function. If they lose
sales because they have a smoking section, then they'll change. If
not, then they were clearly right and shouldn't be forced to change.
What
I'm getting at is that if people want to have higher minimum wages,
don't bitch and whine to your government to do it. Don't force it on
everyone, forcing the cost on everyone. Stop being so shortsighted
and realize what raising the minimum wage will, ultimately do. If you
think that Target should be paying YOU more, than tell them to pay
you and the other employees more. If you think that Sears, HyVee,
CostCo, Barnes & Noble, Pepsi or whoever else then you should be
airing your grievances at THEM because its how they choose to run
their company. And if you don't like it, tell them or find somewhere
else to work that will listen to the employees.
Taking
this a step farther, now, let's discuss those who “need” this
minimum wage increase. Single parents? How did you get into that
situation where you were a single parent? Unplanned pregnancy due to
unprotected sex? Father/mother who left and refuses to pay child
support? If the former, then your financial situation is your own
fault and I could care less if you can't keep your financial
situation in check. You made a choice. It was a bad one. You could
have not had sex. You could have had protection. You could have
aborted or put the kid up for adoption. But you choose everything
that put you into a financially shit situation and the government
should have NO obligation to help you in any way because you're an
idiot. As for the latter, force it out of him. You likely got a
divorce attorney to make sure the other parent lived up to their end
of the bargain, so keep on that.
My
point is, it is and has been, possible to live on low (and lower
wages) before. And driving the wages up is only going to drive costs
up. It's not going to solve the problem and the only thing that will
is by telling people to stop making such terrible life decisions,
putting them in crappy financial situations. But, no. It's just
easier to have the government fix it by throwing more worthless
practically non-existent money at the problem than to actually put
work into improve your life and the lives of those around you. It's
that backwards logic that doesn't make sense to me and I'm hoping
that you'll wake up years from now, look back and see just how this
circular logic got us to where we'll end up.
Hm...
I thought this argument might last me longer but it actually ended up
quite short. Now I'm a bit disappointed. …
I
guess come back for more posts on more things. Hopefully things less
political and more fun and game-related.
No comments:
Post a Comment
I do not care what you have to say to me, so long as it is relevant or insightful in some manner. But do be respectful to others posting their thoughts and opinions here as well or I will start moderating the comments. Thank you.